Gaza and the West’s Historical Predicament

The recent war on Gaza cannot be understood merely as a military confrontation or another episode in the protracted Arab–Israeli conflict. Rather, it constitutes a historical test that has revealed the fragility of the Western moral and political order.

This confrontation has highlighted fissures within a system that has dominated international relations for decades, presenting itself as the sole model of civilization, freedom, and human rights. The unfolding crisis suggests the possible erosion of this hegemony, raising profound questions about the sustainability of the Western-centered global order.

While structural transformations in world politics are generally gradual, the rapid succession and intensification of recent events have rendered the international system more unstable, and the Western bloc more uncertain about its own trajectory.

The confrontation between Islam and the West should not be reduced to a passing conflict. It is, rather, a contest between two divergent value systems. Islam—both as a spiritual and political paradigm—places justice at the core of its project, granting rights without discrimination, fostering a system of consent and altruism, and cultivating inner stability through enduring faith-based principles.

By contrast, the Western order tends to perceive these values as a latent threat to the interests of its ruling elites. Consequently, the West promotes liberalism, democracy, and human rights as universal principles, while in practice these function as ideological instruments that mask underlying materialistic and self-serving tendencies, often privileging the few over the many.

The Gaza war has laid bare the dissonance between rhetoric and reality within the Western discourse, producing two notable ruptures:

1. A widening gap between the normative principles professed by Western states and their actual practices, particularly their unconditional support for Israel and complicity in its actions.

2. A tension between Western societies, where significant segments mobilized in solidarity with Gaza, and Western governments, which either colluded with Israel or confined themselves to rhetorical gestures that underscored political and moral paralysis.

The exposure of these contradictions has opened the possibility for deeper intellectual and ideological reassessments within Western societies.

At present, the West finds itself in an unprecedented strategic predicament. Its image as the guardian of universal human values has been undermined, while its inability to apply its own stated principles consistently—especially in relation to Israel—has become increasingly evident.

Exacerbating this crisis are the policies of the Netanyahu government, characterized by intransigence and a reliance on policies of extermination and starvation. These actions have entangled the West further, intensifying the erosion of its normative foundations and deepening ideological fractures.

The West’s principal anxiety is not a potential military victory by Gaza, but rather the prospect of Islam re-emerging as a civilizational alternative capable of filling any vacuum created by the decline of the Western order. Despite the institutional weaknesses of the contemporary Muslim world, its underlying spiritual and moral resources retain the potential to revitalize an entire civilization.

The current moment, therefore, should not be interpreted as a transient episode but as the beginning of a transformative historical process with the potential to reshape global political configurations and power relations. A further weakening or collapse of the Western system would inevitably reverberate across a wide range of allied political regimes, accelerating systemic dislocations throughout the international order.

In this sense, Gaza transcends its geographical confines and functions as a symbolic compass, revealing the underlying direction of the contemporary civilizational struggle. The war has shaken the normative and institutional pillars of the Western system, compelling both its governments and societies to confront their internal contradictions.

Amidst moral dissonance and political uncertainty, the West now stands at a historical crossroads: it must either engage in genuine self-reflection and reconstruct its normative order, or face the prospect of decline—a process that could fundamentally redraw the contours of the global system.

Support Dawat Media Center

If there were ever a time to join us, it is now. Every contribution, however big or small, powers our journalism and sustains our future. Support the Dawat Media Center from as little as $/€10 – it only takes a minute. If you can, please consider supporting us with a regular amount each month. Thank you
DNB Bank AC # 0530 2294668
Account for international payments: NO15 0530 2294 668
Vipps: #557320

  Donate Here