Washington and Kabul: Rational Mediation and Recalibrating the Path Forward

Recent developments in Afghanistan have reignited opportunities for diplomatic engagement between the Taliban-led government in Kabul and the United States. The visit of Mr. Adam Boehler, along with former U.S. envoy Zalmay Khalilzad, to Kabul—where they met with Mullah Abdul Ghani Baradar, Deputy Prime Minister of Afghanistan—may signal a new chapter in bilateral relations. While the details of these discussions remain undisclosed, the visit carries implicit political weight, suggesting the potential reactivation of dialogue, albeit in indirect form.
This moment invites a critical reassessment of the Doha Agreement, signed in February 2020. Despite representing a landmark diplomatic milestone, the agreement has yet to be fully leveraged to establish a comprehensive and sustainable political framework. In this context, Qatar emerges once again as a credible and capable mediator, well-positioned to play a central role in recalibrating the political process through pragmatic and balanced diplomacy

Afghanistan: Transitioning from Conflict to Isolation

For over four decades, Afghanistan has been entrenched in a cycle of internal conflict and external intervention. Political stability has remained elusive, and socioeconomic development a distant aspiration. The 2021 U.S. withdrawal and the subsequent consolidation of power by the Taliban ushered in a new era defined by heightened international isolation, asset freezes, and the absence of formal diplomatic recognition.

Efforts to revive dialogue between Kabul and Washington have been stymied by a deep trust deficit. The United States maintains firm preconditions—focused on human rights, women’s empowerment, and counterterrorism—while the Taliban government perceives these demands as infringing upon national sovereignty and cultural autonomy.

Qatar: A Trusted, Neutral, and Proactive Diplomatic Actor

Since the inception of U.S.-Taliban negotiations, Qatar has consistently demonstrated its capacity to facilitate dialogue, underpinned by political neutrality, balanced engagement with all stakeholders, and a proven record in regional and international mediation.

Qatar positions itself not only as a neutral intermediary, but as a diplomatic facilitator with the technical and political sophistication to navigate sensitive contexts. Its approach enables the formulation of creative, interest-based solutions without compromising core principles. As such, Qatar is uniquely suited to spearhead a constructive reassessment of the Doha Agreement, aligning it with current geopolitical realities.

The Doha Agreement: An Urgent Need for Evaluation and Renewal

More than five years after its signing, the Doha Agreement remains partially implemented and subject to significant contention. While it successfully facilitated the withdrawal of U.S. forces, it lacked a clear political transition framework and did not establish robust mechanisms for enforcement or monitoring. Consequently, some observers view the agreement more as a security arrangement than a comprehensive political accord.

Against this backdrop, Qatar is well-positioned to lead efforts to revise and expand the agreement’s scope, incorporating unresolved issues such as political inclusivity, minority rights, humanitarian access, and the reintegration of Afghanistan into the international system. The objective should not be to discard the agreement, but rather to modernize it—transforming it into a forward-looking roadmap that reflects the evolving political landscape.

Reviving a Political Culture of Dialogue

Afghanistan’s history should not be defined solely by conflict. The country has produced seminal thinkers—such as Jamal al-Din al-Afghani—who long advocated for political pluralism and institution-building grounded in justice and national unity.

Today, there remains a viable opportunity to revive this political ethos, provided that an inclusive domestic dialogue is facilitated among Afghanistan’s diverse constituencies. Such a process would benefit significantly from regional and international sponsorship, ideally under the aegis of a trusted facilitator like Qatar, capable of fostering a secure environment for genuine national reconciliation.

Direct Negotiations: A Shared Strategic Responsibility

A pressing question arises: Can Washington and Kabul re-engage in direct negotiations?

The answer lies not merely in political will, but in the availability of credible guarantees, the credibility of the mediator, and the prevailing regional and international context.

Given its extensive diplomatic capital and humanitarian track record, Qatar is uniquely equipped to initiate a new phase of engagement—beginning with informal, confidence-building steps, and gradually evolving into formal negotiations through discreet channels. However, success will hinge on close coordination with the international community, ensuring that support is perceived as partnership rather than imposition, and as inclusion rather than oversight.

Conclusion: A Rare Opportunity That Must Not Be Lost

Afghanistan today stands at a critical juncture—marked by an urgent need for transformation and the presence of actors capable of enabling that process.

Qatar, which has previously succeeded in opening diplomatic channels between adversaries, now holds both the opportunity and legitimacy to play a more advanced role in the renewal and operationalization of the Doha Agreement. Its involvement could pave the way for the resumption of structured dialogue between Kabul and Washington.

In an era characterized by complex and protracted conflicts, the value of measured, trust-based diplomacy cannot be overstated. Qatar’s success in facilitating this dialogue would not only contribute to stability in Afghanistan, but also strengthen the global model of consensus-based diplomacy as a viable tool for resolving intractable disputes.

The window for dialogue remains open—but it will not remain so indefinitely.
What is required now is decisive and rational action, before the momentum is lost and the cycle of isolation and escalation resumes.

The Original Article Published is Published in the White House platform in Arabic based in Washington D.C

Support Dawat Media Center

If there were ever a time to join us, it is now. Every contribution, however big or small, powers our journalism and sustains our future. Support the Dawat Media Center from as little as $/€10 – it only takes a minute. If you can, please consider supporting us with a regular amount each month. Thank you
DNB Bank AC # 0530 2294668
Account for international payments: NO15 0530 2294 668
Vipps: #557320

  Donate Here