The Digital ID Landscape: As the UK Proposes a Mandatory ‘Brit Card’, Which European Nations Are Already Ahead?

The United Kingdom’s recent announcement of a mandatory digital ID system for all residents by 2029, dubbed the ‘Brit Card,’ has ignited a fierce national debate. While presented by the government as a tool to streamline public services and enhance border security, it has been met with significant opposition, including a petition of over 2.5 million signatures warning of “mass surveillance and digital control.”

However, the concept of a digital identity is far from novel in a European context. While the UK’s mandatory approach is distinct, many nations on the continent have spent decades refining voluntary systems, offering a window into the potential benefits and complexities of a digital future.

The UK’s Proposal: ‘Brit Card’

The UK government has outlined a plan for an app-based digital ID system to be rolled out by 2029. Key stated objectives include:

• Simplifying Access: Streamlining interactions with healthcare, education, and welfare services.

• Enhancing Security: Reducing administrative burdens and potential fraud through more efficient identity verification.

• Controlling Immigration: Ensuring only those with legal status can work and access public services.

Prime Minister Rishi Sunak framed the initiative as a response to public concern, stating, “I know working people are worried about the level of illegal migration into this country. A secure border and controlled migration are reasonable demands, and this government is listening and delivering.”

Despite these assurances, critics remain vocal, arguing that a mandatory system fundamentally shifts the relationship between the citizen and the state, raising profound privacy and civil liberty questions.

Digital ID Pioneers in Europe: A Voluntary Model

In contrast to the UK’s proposed mandate, most established European systems are either voluntary or function as a digital extension of a compulsory physical ID card. These systems provide a proven blueprint for how digital IDs can integrate into daily life.

1. Estonia: The Gold Standard
Estonia is the undisputed pioneer, having launched its e-ID system nearly two decades ago.

• Functionality: The e-ID is a mandatory national card with a digital chip, used with PIN codes. It allows citizens to vote online, sign legally-binding documents digitally, access their complete medical history, file taxes, and manage banking.

• Impact: The system is estimated to save the economy an impressive 5 working days per year per citizen by eliminating bureaucratic red tape. Today, 99% of Estonians have a digital ID, and the concept is deeply woven into the fabric of society.

2. Denmark: The App-Based Success
Denmark transitioned from its NemID to the more advanced MitID in 2021.

• Functionality: MitID is primarily an app-based solution (though key cards are available) used for logging into everything from bank accounts and government services to public libraries and healthcare portals.

• Adoption: It is used by over 90% of the population and is considered a cornerstone of Denmark’s efficient digital public infrastructure.

3. Belgium: The eID Integration
Belgium has had a compulsory identity card (eID) for all citizens over 12 since 2004.

• Functionality: Each eID contains a digital certificate that allows citizens to authenticate their identity online and sign documents electronically. It is used for tax declarations, municipal services, and accessing personal government records.

• Foundation: The system’s success is built on the ubiquity of the physical card, with the digital functions being a seamless extension.

4. Spain: The Electronic DNI
Spain introduced its electronic DNI (DNIe) in 2006.

• Evolution: The early version required a card reader. It has since evolved, and the current model, supplemented by the MiDNI smartphone app, allows for contactless use and easier integration with mobile devices for authenticating online services.

5. Germany: The eID Function on National ID Cards
Since 2010, all German national ID cards have contained an embedded RFID chip with eID functionality.

• Voluntary Use: While the physical card is mandatory, the online eID function is voluntary. Citizens can use it with a PIN to prove their identity to government portals, for official mail, and increasingly, for private sector services like car rentals or contract signings.

The EU-Wide Push: eIDAS 2.0 and the Digital Identity Wallet

Recognizing the fragmented state of digital identity across the bloc, the European Union is spearheading a major harmonization effort. The eIDAS 2.0 regulation aims to create a common framework.

• The Goal: Require all member states to provide their citizens with a Digital Identity Wallet by 2026.

• Interoperability: This wallet will be recognized across the EU, allowing a citizen from Portugal to, for example, securely open a bank account in Finland or access medical records in South Korea using their home country’s digital ID.

• Current Status: Large-scale pilot projects are already underway across all 26 EU member states, as well as Norway, Iceland, and Ukraine, involving hundreds of public and private sector partners.

Key Distinctions and The Road Ahead

The critical difference between the UK’s plan and most existing European models lies in the principle of voluntariness. European systems have typically gained public trust through utility and convenience, often building upon existing, trusted identity documents. The UK’s proposal for a mandatory, standalone system represents a different philosophical approach, one that immediately raises the stakes in the debate over privacy and state power.

As the UK moves forward, it will not be inventing the wheel but will be closely observing its European neighbours—learning from both their successes in efficiency and their challenges in building and maintaining public trust in the digital age.

Support Dawat Media Center

If there were ever a time to join us, it is now. Every contribution, however big or small, powers our journalism and sustains our future. Support the Dawat Media Center from as little as $/€10 – it only takes a minute. If you can, please consider supporting us with a regular amount each month. Thank you
DNB Bank AC # 0530 2294668
Account for international payments: NO15 0530 2294 668
Vipps: #557320

  Donate Here